Nathan Cleary is free to play in Penrith’s mouthwatering season-opener against premiers Brisbane after Panthers coach Ivan Cleary successfully represented his son in a hearing at the NRL judiciary.

Not since the late Bob Fulton represented his son Scott during the late 1990s has a father-son duo fronted the judiciary, but the Clearys successfully argued for a downgrade and $1800 fine of Nathan’s high shot on Wests Tigers prodigy Heamasi Makasini last Friday night.

In matching black jackets, dress shirts and chinos (with football CEO Matt Cameron, football manager Shane Elford and media manager Michael Blok also attending in matching outfits), Ivan won over the judiciary panel after 38 minutes of evidence, arguing that Nathan’s hit was initially to Makasini’s shoulder and warranted a reduction from the initial Grade 2 charge.

The Clearys illustrated their point to judiciary panellists Ryan James and Greg McCallum with three still shots of Nathan making initial contact of “right shoulder to right shoulder”, as the champion playmaker explained his rush out of the line to ensure he didn’t become a defensive “speed bump”.

“I’m looking at [Makasini and he is looking at me, which I believe is why he juggled the ball,” Nathan said as footage of the contact was replayed.

“I deliberately lowered my arm because if I didn’t, I believe I would have hit him in the head. I believe the contact was shoulder to shoulder. I also hit the ball and that’s why it was dislodged.”

After just 12 minutes of deliberation, the judiciary panel agreed unanimously, with Cleary’s initial contact ruled to have been with Makasini’s shoulder.

NRL counsel Lachlan Giles declined to cross-examine Cleary. He instead addressed the judiciary panel and argued Cleary “continued his acceleration” out of the defensive line “through the target” for a level of force consistent with a grade 2 charge.