Judge certifies class-action lawsuit over COVID-19 deaths at Maples care home in Winnipeg | CBC News


Judge certifies class-action lawsuit over COVID-19 deaths at Maples care home in Winnipeg | CBC News

Listen to this article

Estimated 4 minutes

The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results.

A class-action lawsuit naming the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority and the former operator of a long-term care home that was the site of Manitoba’s deadliest COVID-19 outbreak is going ahead.

Court of King’s Bench Associate Chief Justice Shane Perlmutter has certified the lawsuit launched by children of Ethel Lewsey, 99, and Manuel Calisto, 88, two of 56 residents whose deaths were linked to an outbreak at the Maples Long Term Care Home that was declared on Oct. 20, 2020, and lasted until Jan. 12, 2021.

The class includes anyone who contracted COVID-19 as a Maples resident during the outbreak, as well as the estate of those who died then as well as their family members as defined under the Fatal Accidents Act.

“There is some basis in fact for the determination of the alleged breaches as common issues,” Perlmutter said in a Feb. 2 decision certifying the class action.

“It is uncontested that Maples had the highest attack rate (78.5 per cent) and percentage of deaths (23.5 per cent) of the 10 personal care homes in the category of large personal care homes in Winnipeg,” he wrote.

During the nearly three-month-long Maples outbreak, 157 residents living in the 200-bed facility tested positive for the virus, according to a report commissioned by Manitoba Health. As well, 74 staff working at the home tested positive during the outbreak.

The outbreak prompted an external review that made 17 recommendations for the care home, the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, and for Manitoba’s health incident command structure and health department.

‘We cannot forget what happened’: plaintiff 

The representative plaintiffs for the class action, Eddie Calisto-Tavares and Lawrence Lewsey, allege Revera, the for-profit operator then in charge of the care home, was negligent and did not adequately plan for or respond to the outbreak.

They claimed the Winnipeg health authority failed to immediately address staffing shortages in the care home, among other issues. 

Calisto-Tavares received special permission to enter Maples during the COVID-19 lockdown and care for her father, Manuel Calisto, on what were his last days alive after contracting the virus.

Eddie Calisto-Tavares was granted permission to enter the Maples Long Term Care Home and care for her father during a COVID-19 outbreak at the facility. (Walther Bernal/CBC)

The certification of the class action lawsuit brings a moment of joy for Calisto-Tavares, who wants the court process to bring awareness of what residents experienced at the long-term care home during the outbreak.

“We cannot forget what happened. Those residents, regardless of age and regardless of where they were in their life cycle, they mattered,” she told CBC on Saturday.

She is hopeful recounting her father’s experience and those of other class action members will act as a reminder of lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic, and she hopes that higher standards of care will follow the suit.

“I’m now a senior. I’m 67 years old and I have no idea what the future holds. But while I have a voice … I will continue to fight for this,” she said.

Darryl Singer, head of the class action group at Diamond & Diamond Lawyers, said his team and the representative plaintiffs felt a sense of “elation” after the class-action lawsuit was certified. 

Singer said it’s often difficult for class-action lawsuits to “get over that hump” of the certification process. Now that it will be moving forward, he said that the “real work is going to begin.”

He said his clients are “seeking change” alongside financial compensation.

The allegations in the lawsuit have not been tested in court.

Shared Health and the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority told CBC News they can’t comment on this matter because it is before the courts.

CBC has contacted Revera for comment.

Extendicare took over the long-term care homes Revera was operating in Ontario and Manitoba in 2023.

In 2024, the Ontario Superior Court certified six class-action lawsuits on behalf of long-term care residents who contracted COVID-19 during the pandemic, including one naming Revera.


No 10 claims Starmer ‘positive, confident and determined’ despite resignation of two key aides in 24 hours – UK politics live


No 10 claims Starmer ‘positive, confident and determined’, despite resignation of two key aides within 24 hours

The No 10 lobby briefing has just finished. Here are the main points.

  • Keir Starmer is “positive, confident and determined”, the PM’s spokespeson told journalists. He said:

The prime minister is getting on with the job of delivering change across the country. That was the tone and the content of his address to staff in No 10 this morning.

Asked about the PM’s mood, the spokesperson said:

He was upbeat, confident in his speech to staff this morning. He spoke about how he’s driven by the values of public service. He talked about how that was what brought him into politics later in life after a career, most recently as director of public prosecutions … [He was] positive, confident and determined.

When it was put to the spokesperson there were reports saying Starmer was very depressed at the end of last week, and that he was even contemplating resigning, the spokesperson replied:

That’s not the prime minister who appeared in front of staff this morning.

The question was referring to stories like this one in the Times on Saturday, which said: One cabinet minister predicted that Starmer could quit on Monday after he had taken the opportunity to reflect on the events of recent days with his wife, Victoria.

  • The spokesperson played down suggestions that Allan was sacked, pointing out that Allan said in his statement (see 11.15am) he had decided to stand down.

  • The spokesperson played down suggestions that Allan may have quit because he is worried about embarrassing messages between him and Peter Mandelson being released as a result of the humble address motion passed by MPs on Wednesday. It is understood that the process of finding information that will have to be disclosed has only just got underway.

Share

Key events

Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, is holding a press conference in Glasgow at 2.30pm. There is speculation that he may use this to call for Keir Starmer’s resignation. Chris Mason, the BBC’s political editor, has just told the World at One that Sarwar’s office have been offered the chance to say he won’t be doing that, but that they’re not replying.

Share


US not trying to dismantle Nato or undermine world order, says ambassador – Europe live


US not trying to dismantle Nato or undermine current world order, US ambassador says in response to MSC’s criticism report

US ambassador to Nato Matthew Whitaker is responding to some of the report’s findings now, saying he “completely rejects everything I just heard,” after the Munich Security Conference report editors warned that the greatest challenge to the liberal international order is “coming from within” through the dramatic shift in the US administration’s thinking about its alliances (11:54).

But Whitaker insists the US does not want to dismantle Nato or undermine the existing alliances as implied by the report’s authors, but merely to “balance” the way the defence burden lies on different Nato countries by pushing European allies to “do more and to be capable and strong, because that strength is what guarantees the peace.”

“That’s the first thing I reject; we’re trying to make Nato stronger, not to withdraw or reject Nato, but make it work like it was intended as an alliance of 32 strong and capable allies,” he said.

Whitaker also said that on trade, the US wanted to challenge the “unfair” trade arrangement with Europe, which “turned into Europe taking advantage and running huge trade surplus with the US.”

He also said that the US was frustrated that “there is a lot of discussion and not a lot of action” in Europe, with allies spending more time to discuss issues rather than address them.

Whitaker says that on security, the European partners need to actually step up their defence spending and show they can “follow through” on their promises, including the new Nato spending targets.

He then gets pushed on Greenland, and insists the US interest in the territory is only about ensuring that Greenland – whether as part of Denmark or an independent country in the future – needs to be able to defend itself from Russia and China.

“The Chinese have taken two runs, at least at Greenland; one through the ports trying to invest in the ports and second, through trying to invest in the airport, and so these are real issues,” he claims (something that has been repeatedly questioned by the Danish officials.)

He then distances himself a bit from Trump’s aggressive rhetoric there, saying that he learned during the first Trump administration that “responding to every single Truth Social or tweet by president Trump would be a full-time job,” but insists the underlying security analysis is sound.

Share

Key events

Whitaker’s comments on Nato, EU offer taster of what’s to come up in Munich this week – snap analysis

US not trying to dismantle Nato or undermine world order, says ambassador – Europe live

Jakub Krupa

I think we got a good taster of what sort of policy discussions and themes are going to come up this weekend as key EU, US security and foreign policy experts meet in Munich.

US secretary of state Marco Rubio, fresh from his Olympic appearance in Italy, will be the highest US representative at the event and is expected to deliver a speech at some point on Saturday.

Doubt it will be quite as combative, or “provocative” as Whitaker put it, as that JD Vance speech last year, but make sure to save the date and follow our coverage from Munich over the weekend.

Share


Search for Nancy Guthrie continues into 9th day after family says, ‘we will pay’


Faced with a demand for a bitcoin ransom and a Monday deadline by someone claiming to be her mother’s kidnapper, “Today” host Savannah Guthrie and her siblings over the weekend solemnly pledged to pay for the return of their mother, Nancy.

“We received your message and we understand,” Savannah Guthrie said in a message posted to Instagram. “We beg you now to return our mother to us so we can celebrate with her. This is the only way we will have peace. This is very valuable to us, and we will pay.”

Nancy Guthrie, 84, was last seen Jan. 31, and authorities have said they believe she was abducted from her home near Tucson, Arizona.

Search for Nancy Guthrie continues into 9th day after family says, ‘we will pay’

U.S. journalist and television host Savannah Guthrie, accompanied by her siblings Annie and Camron, speaks in a video message, addressing that they are willing to pay for the release of their elderly mother, Nancy Guthrie, who went missing from her Arizona home several days ago, in this screen grab obtained from social media video taken at an unspecified location and released February 7, 2026. Savannah Guthrie via Instagram/via REUTERS

Savannah Guthrie Via Instagram/via Reuters

“We are aware of the video posted by the Guthrie family. But don’t have any additional information to share,” a spokesperson for Pima Sheriff said in a statement to ABC News on Saturday following the release of the latest video from the family.

The message Savannah Guthrie references in her new Instagram post is the same message the FBI and Pima Sheriff said they were studying Friday, according to a source familiar with the investigation.

Investigators have not confirmed the authenticity of the latest message, which was received by a Tucson television station, nor any of the other ransom notes mentioning Nancy Guthrie, according to the source.

PHOTO: Savannah Guthrie Mom Missing

In this image provided by NBCUniversal, Savannah Guthrie, right, her mom Nancy speak, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in New York.

Nathan Congleton/AP

Investigators have returned repeatedly to the home of Annie Guthrie, Nancy’s other daughter, were Nancy enjoyed dinner and a Saturday game night before returning to her home a few minutes away.

Investigators have also returned to Nancy’s home, where they’ve examined rooftop cameras, towed away a car and made inquiries of neighbors.

The sheriff’s department said, “This remains an active and ongoing investigation,” but added that, after more than a week, “Investigators have not identified any suspects, persons of interest, or vehicles connected to this case.”

ABC News’ Nadine El-Bawab contributed to this report.


Charlie Spikes the Ball: Turning Point USA’s All-American Halftime Show Wins the Super Bowl


The Turning Point USA All-American Halftime show kicked off Sunday night to millions of fans who streamed the patriotic event online, an alternative to Bad Bunny’s Spanish-only Super Bowl 60 intermission that ended with the Puerto Rican pop star making a politically charged immigration message.

“Welcome to the Turning Point USA All-American Halftime show. And this one’s for you, Charlie,” host Jack Posobiec said, honoring Turning Point USA’s late founder Charlie Kirk, before a rousing electric guitar rendition of “The Star Spangled Banner” was played by Brantley Gilbert.

Gilbert got the concert started with a patriotic version of “Real American,” followed by a powerful rendition of Jason Aldean’s “Dirt Road Anthem.”

Gabby Barrett emerged from a near-pitch black space in the stage while the audience erupted in applause, as she opened with her massive hit “I Hope.” The country crooner followed that up with “The Good Ones.”

The YouTube stream was hovering around four and half million live viewers  just as Lee Brice’s seven-minute set kicked off. That number jumped to over five million viewers as Brice began belting out lyrics from his mega hit “Drinking Class.”

Before his next song, Brice honored Charlie Kirk, saying “Charlie, he gave people microphones so they could say what was on their mind. This is what’s on mine.” Brice lifted his guitar and sang his new edgy, politically charged track called “Country Nowadays.”

“Country Nowadays” lyrics:

It ain’t easy being country in this country nowadays
The direction the fingers point when everything goes up in flames
Saying I’m some right wing devil ’cause I was red letter Jesus raised
It ain’t easy being country in this country nowadays

Brice ended his set with a hard-charging rendition of his hit “Hard to Love.”

Up next was Kid Rock, who came on to close and he brought the energy to a new height with his classic track “Bawitdaba,” before switching the mode to mellow as he covered Cody Johnson’s #1 smash hit “Til You Can’t.” Rock added his own verse to the song, in which he evangelized about reading the Bible and serving Jesus Christ.

“There’s a book sitting in your house somewhere that could use some dusting off / There’s a man who died for all our sins hanging from the cross / You can give your life to Jesus and he’ll give you a second chance / Till you can’t,” Kid Rock sang.

The Kirk tribute played on the screen showing viewers a montage of photos of Kirk and his widow, Erika Kirk and their children.




The AI wars begin with new Super Bowl commercials


NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

First it was the Pepsi-Cola war, then it was the PC versus Apple, and now the AI wars have begun. 

The burgeoning rivalry between the world’s leading artificial intelligence firms moved away from the Silicon Valley boardroom to the television screen on Sunday.

AI startup Anthropic made its Super Bowl LX debut with a high-stakes ad campaign that took a direct swipe at its chief competitor, OpenAI. The commercials, which reportedly cost millions to air during the match-up between the Seattle Seahawks and New England Patriots, mock OpenAI’s recent decision to introduce advertisements within its popular chatbot, ChatGPT.

One 30-second spot features a young man asking a muscular bystander for workout advice. The bystander responds in a stilted, robotic tone before abruptly pivoting to a sales pitch for shoe insoles that help “short kings stand tall.” The ad concludes with a pointed tagline: “Ads are coming to AI. But not to Claude.”

PALANTIR’S SHYAM SANKAR: HERE’S WHAT EXECUTIVES AND LEADERS USING AI SHOULD DO

The AI wars begin with new Super Bowl commercials

An ad for Claude, Anthropic’s AI model. (Anthropic)

Anthropic, the San Francisco-based firm founded by former OpenAI executives, is positioning itself as the more principled alternative to the Microsoft-backed giant. In a blog post released alongside the campaign, Anthropic said its AI model Claude will “remain ad-free.”

“There are many good places for advertising. A conversation with Claude is not one of them,” the blog post read. “Claude will remain ad-free. Our users won’t see ‘sponsored’ links adjacent to their conversations with Claude; nor will Claude’s responses be influenced by advertisers or include third-party product placements our users did not ask for.”

Anthropic declined to provide further comment. 

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman responded to the ads on X, calling them “clearly dishonest” and accused Anthropic of “double speak.”

“But I wonder why Anthropic would go for something so clearly dishonest,” he wrote. “I guess it’s on brand for Anthropic doublespeak to use a deceptive ad to critique theoretical deceptive ads that aren’t real, but a Super Bowl ad is not where I would expect it.”

AI COMPANIONS ARE RESHAPING TEEN EMOTIONAL BONDS

Laptop open to ChatGPT.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman responded to Anthropic’s ads forcefully, calling them “clearly dishonest.”  (Gabby Jones/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Altman defended the decision to test ads in the “Free” and “Go” tiers of ChatGPT as a necessity for maintaining broad accessibility. He contrasted OpenAI’s scale with Anthropic’s, stating that “more Texans use ChatGPT for free than all the people in the United States who use Claude.”

“Anthropic serves an expensive product to rich people,” Altman added. “We also feel strongly that we need to bring AI to billions of people who can’t pay for subscriptions.”

Altman also responded to the ads on the TBPN podcast (The Technology Brothers Podcast) with hosts John Coogan and Jordi Hays. He said his company isn’t “stupid” and that they respect OpenAI users.

“We’re not stupid,” Altman told the hosts. “We respect our users, and we understand that if we did something like what those ads depict, people would rightfully stop using our product.”

The company has stated that ads will not influence answers and advertisers will not have access to users’ conversations. According to OpenAI, ads will be labeled and at the bottom of the screen. 

OpenAI didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

95% OF FACULTY SAY AI MAKING STUDENTS DANGEROUSLY DEPENDENT ON TECHNOLOGY FOR LEARNING: SURVEY

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks in July

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks during the Federal Reserve’s Integrated Review of the Capital Framework for Large Banks Conference in Washington, D.C., July 22, 2025.  (Ken Cedeno/Reuters)

The TBPN hosts, who have become influential voices in the Silicon Valley ecosystem, offered a split verdict on the escalating conflict.

“It’s incredibly clever. And it’s incredibly dirty,” Hays said, ading that the “gloves are off” between the two companies. 

Coogan characterized the ads as “fake newsy,” but noted that it represents a significant shift in how these companies view one another. 

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

OpenAI also had a presence during the big game, using airtime to promote its software coding tool, Codex, as it seeks to maintain its dominant market position amid a “code red” competitive environment.

The AI wars are no longer just about who has the smartest model—they are now about who can win the hearts and minds of the largest television audience of the year.


Starmer’s comms director steps down day after his chief of staff quits



Starmer’s comms director steps down day after his chief of staff quits

Sir Keir Starmer’s director of communications has stepped down the day after the prime minister’s most senior aide quit.

Tim Allan, a former adviser to Tony Blair, had only started at No 10 in September in a bid to steady the ship.

He is Sir Keir’s fourth head of communications since Labour won the election in July 2024.

Mr Allan said: “I have decided to stand down to allow a new No 10 team to be built.

“I wish the PM and his team every success.”

His departure comes less than 24 hours after Sir Keir’s right-hand man, Morgan McSweeney, resigned over his role in appointing Lord Mandelson as ambassador to the US after further links to the paedophile financier Jeffrey Epstein were revealed.

The resignation of two of Sir Keir’s inner circle will prompt further calls for the prime minister to also go.

This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly.

Please refresh the page for the fullest version.

You can receive Breaking News alerts on a smartphone or tablet via the Sky News App. You can also follow @SkyNews on X or subscribe to our YouTube channel to keep up with the latest news.


Wedding ceremony during Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl half-time show was genuine


Yes, the wedding ceremony during Bad Bunny’s historic Super Bowl half-time show – the first where a headliner performed entirely in Spanish – was genuine.

About five minutes into the Puerto Rican artist‘s 13-minute performance at Levi’s Stadium in California, cameras panned to a couple’s wedding ceremony.

“I declare you husband and wife, you can kiss the bride,” a smiling officiant declared in Spanish.

The newlyweds then parted to reveal Lady Gaga and Los Sobrinos, a Puerto Rican salsa band who played on Bad Bunny’s most recent album and at his Puerto Rican residency.

The couple are serenaded by Gaga, who sings “Die With A Smile,” before cameras focus in on the couple cutting their wedding cake and dancing to Bad Bunny’s “Baile Inolvidable” (Unforgettable Dance).

Wedding ceremony during Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl half-time show was genuine
Image:
Not many weddings see two of the world’s most successful singers taking part in the first dance. Pic: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The star, who recently won album of the year at the Grammys, performed on a heavily Puerto Rican-inspired stage.

After the show, his representative confirmed that the couple had actually been married during the show.

The unnamed husband and wife had invited Bad Bunny to their wedding, but he said they should instead be part of his half-time show.

The artist served as a witness and signed their marriage certificate.

The wedding scene, which recreated a small outdoor plaza, was part of the show’s greater celebration of Puerto Rico.

The scene quickly went viral, with one person commenting on the NFL’s official YouTube video of the performance: “Imagine being in your 80s telling your grandchildren you got to have a wedding in the Super Bowl”.

Another jokingly commented, “‘How many people came to your wedding?’

“‘Idk (I don’t know), like 70,000’ – that couple”.

Bad Bunny won the album of the year at the 2026 Grammys.P Pic: AP
Image:
Bad Bunny won the album of the year at the 2026 Grammys.P Pic: AP

The joyous half-time show was labelled as the “worst ever” by US President Donald Trump.

Trump, who attended last year’s show, called Bad Bunny’s show “an affront to the Greatness of America”.

“Nobody understands a word this guy is saying,” he added.

Mr Trump’s administration has long been hostile to the use of Spanish within the US.

Read more from Sky News:
More than 100 flood warnings issued as further rain forecast
Toddler held by ICE ‘nearly died’ in detention

Within hours of Trump’s second inauguration in 2025, the new administration took down the Spanish-language version of the official White House website.

Jennifer Lopez unveiled a reversible US and Puerto Rican flag during her 2020 Super Bowl performance. Pic: Reuters
Image:
Jennifer Lopez unveiled a reversible US and Puerto Rican flag during her 2020 Super Bowl performance. Pic: Reuters

The president shut down the Spanish version of the website during his first term. It was restored when President Joe Biden was inaugurated in 2021.

In March 2025, Trump signed an executive order designating English as the official language of the United States.

The order allows government agencies and organisations which receive federal funding to choose whether to continue to offer documents and services in languages other than English.

According to a 2022 US Census Bureau report, 67.8 million (almost one in five) people in the US spoke a language other than English at home in 2019.


Police officer suspended from driving after getting stuck in car trap


The police officer was responding to an emergency when they drove into the car trap

A police officer has been suspended from driving after getting stuck in the notorious car trap on the Guided Busway in Cambridgeshire. Cambridgeshire Police has confirmed a police car got stuck in the car trap on Station Road in St Ives on Saturday, February 7.

The police car was responding to an emergency when it became stuck in the car trap at around 12:40am. The police have reported that no one was injured during the incident.

The vehicle was recovered from the area at around 3am. An investigation into the crash is underway.

A spokesperson for Cambridgeshire Police said: “A police vehicle was responding to an emergency when it became stuck in a car trap in Station Road, St Ives at about 12.40am on 7 February. No injuries sustained.

“Vehicle was recovered by about 3am. The officer has been suspended from driving while an investigation takes place.”

To get more breaking news and top stories delivered directly to your phone, join our new WhatsApp community. Click this link to receive your daily dose of CambridgeshireLive content.

We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.